Top five Middlesbrough captains of all time, ranked

Take a look at every Middlesbrough captain in the club’s history, with a ranking of the top five so far.

Middlesbrough have had some simply superb players join their ranks over the years, all playing a part in successful spells for the club.

From European nights to League Cup success, Boro have had their fair share of highs in the modern era.

However, very few of Middlesbrough’s best players got the chance to wear the captain’s armband to lead the team out to battle.

Of the players that were afforded the honour, only a few truly stepped up and led Boro to glory.

With this in mind, Boro News have taken a look at every Middlesbrough captain and ranked the top five.

Photo by Colin Robertson/Mirrorpix/Getty Images

Middlesbrough’s most successful captains

5 – Brian Clough

Brian Clough began his senior career with his hometown club of Middlesbrough in 1955.

The striker quickly became a local hero thanks to his prolific goalscoring record. Clough found the net 204 times in 222 games for Boro and remains one of the Football League’s highest goalscorers.

Clough was handed the armband in 1958, despite only being 23 years of age at the time, and held onto it until his transfer to Sunderland in 1961.

4 – Tony Mowbray

Tony Mowbray will go down as one of Middlesbrough’s all-time greatest captains following his role in rescuing the club from the threat of extinction.

Steve Gibson saved the Teessiders from liquidation in 1986, with Mowbray handed the armband in the same year.

Boro sat in the Third Division ahead of the 1986/87 campaign but returned to the First Division within three seasons, in no small part due to Mowbray leading the line.

Mowbray gave up the captaincy in 1991 when he left Middlesbrough for Sunderland.

3 – Nigel Pearson

Photo by Bob Thomas Sports Photography via Getty Images

Middlesbrough signed Nigel Pearson from Sheffield Wednesday in 1994, with the defender instantly handed the captaincy by manager, Bryan Robson.

Pearson was the epitome of a no-nonsense skipper who led by example and took no prisoners. He kept hold of the armband until 1998 when he retired.

During his time as captain, Pearson guided Middlesbrough to two Premier League promotions, two League Cup finals, and an FA Cup final.

2 – Grant Leadbitter

Middlesbrough’s most recent promotion to the Premier League following the 2015/16 season would not have been possible without Grant Leadbitter.

After two years of impressing in a subpar team, incoming manager Aitor Karanka handed Leadbitter the captaincy ahead of 2014/15 and was rewarded for his decision.

The midfielder’s aggressive leadership helped guide Boro to the Championship play-off final in 2015 before they secured promotion in 2015/16.

Leadbitter fell out of favour following the Reds’ return to the top flight but his contribution to their promotion charge in the mid 2010s cannot be understated.

1 – Gareth Southgate

Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images

One of the all-time greats at Middlesbrough, Gareth Southgate has to go down as the best captain in the club’s history.

As fans of the England national team are likely aware, Southgate does not possess that aggressive nature some may desire from a skipper.

However, Southgate was Middlesbrough’s captain during the club’s most successful period and for that alone, he should be number one.

The centre-back held the armband between 2004-2008, during which time Middlesbrough won the League Cup and reached the UEFA Cup final.

Every Middlesbrough captain

1900s

  • Peter McCracken
  • William Higgins
  • David Smith
  • Tim Williamson
  • Sam Aitken
  • Alf Common

1910s

  • George Elliott
  • Andy Jackson

1920s

  • Billy Birrell
  • Reg Freeman
  • Joseph Peacock

1930s

  • Joseph Peacock
  • John Jennings
  • Tom Griffiths
  • Bobby Baxter

1940s

  • George Hardwick

1950s

  • Jimmy Gordon
  • Ronald Dicks
  • Bill Harris
  • Brian Clough

1960s

  • Brian Clough
  • Bill Harris
  • Mel Nurse
  • Gordon Jones

1970s

Photo by Bob Thomas Sports Photography via Getty Images
  • Gordon Jones
  • Jim Platt
  • Nobby Stiles

1980s

  • John Craggs
  • Tony McAndrew
  • Irving Nattrass
  • Brian Laws
  • Tony Mowbray

1990s

13 Jan 2001: Paul Ince of Middlesbrough runs with the ball during the FA Carling Premiership match against Derby County played at the Riverside St…
  • Tony Mowbray
  • Alan Kernaghan
  • John Hendrie
  • Nigel Pearson
  • Andy Townsend
  • Paul Ince

2000s

Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images
  • Paul Ince
  • Gareth Southgate
  • George Boateng
  • Emanuel Pogatetz

2010s

Photo by Gareth Copley/Getty Images
  • Matthew Bates
  • Rhys Williams
  • Jonathan Woodgate
  • Grant Leadbitter
  • George Friend

2020s

Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images