DEAR MISS MANNERS: Please let me know your thoughts on a neighbor who “kindly” advised that although we will not be invited to her daughter’s baby shower, we should still purchase gifts for her soon-to-be-grandchild (using the provided link to a baby registry).
She said she had planned to host a baby shower in our neighborhood and invite her daughter, who lives nearby, to join us, but will not be able to due to some health risks. This information was provided via text to a large group of neighbors.
Is this over the proverbial top, regarding etiquette? Or is it a newly accepted way to provide for one’s grandchild? Typically, a shower is a lovely and special way for ladies (or whoever attends) to bond and giggle and share stories, but I’m not quite sure what to think about this request.
I’d also like some guidance in responding, since the text message was sent to many people. Some are replying with their happiness and healthy wishes for the new baby, and some are actually responding with the gift they plan to send.
Further, the sex of this child is the same as the family’s first child, which should mean that many items could be used again. There was a huge shower for the other child a few years ago; does every baby need a new stroller and bathtub?
GENTLE READER: The lovely and special gathering you have in mind is obviously not your neighbor’s purpose in having a shower.
But even if it were, the appearance of acquisitiveness is why there is an (often-violated) rule against giving showers for one’s immediate family.
Miss Manners gathers that you are not among those who are so happy about this pregnancy as to want to send presents. In that case, you need offer only your congratulations.
(Please send your questions to Miss Manners at her website, www.missmanners.com; to her email, dearmissmanners@gmail.com; or through postal mail to Miss Manners, Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106.)
